• About Us
  • Readers Write
  • Our People
Carthage Magazine
  • Home
  • News
  • Food & Drinks
    • Taste Tunisia
  • People
    • Interviews
    • No Sugarcoating
    • Environment
  • Style & Travel
    • Attractions
    • Trip Planning
      • Travel Information
      • Hotels in Tunisia
      • Cost of Living
      • Tunisia’s Language
      • Tunisia’s Weather
      • Tunisia’s Currency
      • Tunisia’s Visa
    • Transport in Tunisia
      • Traveling Around
      • Local Transport
      • Flights to Tunisia
      • Ferries to Tunisia
      • Tunisia Overland
    • Things to Do
      • Leisure
  • Local History
    • Museums
    • Monuments
    • Heritage Sites
    • Historical Figures
  • Education
  • Tech & Startups
  • Editors’ Picks
News

The Tunisia-EU Deal is ‘Dead’6 min read

By Contributing Editor October 5, 2023
Written by Contributing Editor October 5, 2023
Tunisia Europe Deal

By: Ameni Naffeti.

In July, a group of European politicians, including European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, and Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte, secured a new agreement with Tunisian President Kais Saied.

The agreement was not limited to the EU’s relationship with Tunisia; rather, it could serve as a model for similar agreements with other countries in which the EU intended to combine cooperation on migration with economic engagement. However, this did not last long.

This week, the Tunisian government announced that it would not accept an instalment of funds from the EU, including direct budget support and assistance for migration management, because it deemed it to be an inadequate implementation of both the letter and the spirit of the July agreement.

Relations between the EU and Tunisia have been tumultuous for the past few weeks. There is still some confusion on the EU side as to what exactly Tunisia’s government is objecting to.

In September, following a heated debate in the European Parliament regarding Tunisia, Tunisia denied entrance to a delegation of European parliamentarians. The visit of a European Commission delegation was postponed last week.

Even though the future of this relationship is uncertain, the tragic errors and misunderstandings of the past few months have already provided a valuable lesson for EU policy. The Tunisia case is not a model for other agreements; rather, it serves as a reminder that a deal on paper without a more genuine, broader agreement will soon fall apart.

Fundamentally, the problems with the EU-Tunisia agreement stem from a persistent dearth of agreement and a shared objective on multiple levels. The EU itself is the first level.

The Tunisia agreement was a product of the European Commission, influenced by the perspectives of member states. Meloni, the right-wing Italian prime minister, played a pivotal role in securing the agreement and establishing it as a model for future agreements. However, the EU has not reached a consensus on this matter.

In the weeks following the agreement, the European Parliament and diplomats from a wide variety of countries, including Germany, expressed explicit dissatisfaction with both the agreement itself and its role as a model for expansion. Some of this frustration was procedural; the commission’s decision to move forward with the agreement without adequate consultation may have violated EU rules.

Other opposition is more normative, pertaining to the grave violations of human rights against migrants in Tunisia over the past few months, the country’s rapid descent into authoritarian rule, and the escalation of political prisoners. Numerous European policymakers have expressed doubts about the viability of a deeper partnership on migration in light of these issues.

The EU Ombudsman has recently asked the European Commission to explain how the treaty will ensure that human rights are respected, and has given the Commission until December to respond. Without an internal consensus on this matter, the EU may not be a reliable party to this agreement.

The second disagreement between the EU and the Tunisian government undermines the EU-Tunisia agreement. While the July visit produced photo opportunities and a text that pointed to a variety of prospective areas for collaboration, it did not give the impression that Tunisian and European policymakers had a truly shared vision regarding economic cooperation and migration governance. That is because none exist.

Considering the actual practice of migration governance in Tunisia, for instance, where Saied’s dabbling in various discriminatory narratives should have been a red flag for a long time, as well as economic cooperation and Tunisia’s economic future, there are still divergent interests.

One example is that the vast majority of the potential funds mentioned by the EU are dependent on Tunisia reaching a new agreement with the International Monetary Fund, a process that has been stalled for some time and revolves around extremely contentious issues regarding Tunisian state expenditures and subsidies.

Moreover, the lack of trust between both parties is becoming increasingly evident. This is also due to the fact that each side speaks predominantly to its internal audience. What Meloni and other European politicians intend to project to their constituents is diametrically opposed to what Saied intends to project.

While the president of Tunisia’s policies and priorities have frequently been inconsistent, his insistence on Tunisian sovereignty and reliance on a discourse of national self-determination have been consistent and must be considered very seriously.

The third lack of accord that undermines the relationship between the EU and Tunisia is internal to Tunisia. While Saied has dismantled the country’s democratic institutions in order to accumulate enormous presidential power, his political rhetoric has frequently been somewhat antagonistic.

He has made it plain what he does not want: foreign dictates, subsidy cuts, and being the EU’s migration manager. However, he has been less explicit on his vision for Tunisia’s economic development in relation to migration and the role of international actors.

Some of this may be a negotiation tactic, but it is increasingly unclear whether any clear vision actually exists, and whether it would be compatible not only with the preferences of international partners, but with the domestic political actors and institutions that would be required to implement it. In the absence of this, Saied is a highly unreliable and dysfunctional partner due to confusion and public spats with the EU.

There is a possibility that Saied is out of sync not only with other state actors in Tunisia, but also with the Tunisian people. Any deeper engagement between the EU and Tunisia would inevitably have significant long-term consequences for the country’s populace.

All the confusion surrounding the EU-Tunisia deal has significant implications for the EU’s foreign policy and its relations with Tunisia. This agreement serves as a reminder that written agreements do not provide solutions unless there is greater alignment and a shared vision among the involved parties – including the EU and its partners.

This will be impossible without a more serious approach to humanitarian issues and a thorough recognition of the political context in places like Tunisia. A failure to do so is likely to result in further confusion, which, as the ongoing tragedies in the Mediterranean and the deteriorating living conditions in an increasingly authoritarian Tunisia demonstrate, has real and severe humanitarian consequences.


If you would like to comment on this article or anything else you have seen on Carthage Magazine, leave a comment below or head over to our Facebook, Twitter and Instagram pages. You may also message us via this page.

And if you liked this article, sign up for the monthly features newsletter. A handpicked selection of stories from Carthage Magazine, delivered to your inbox.

opinion
0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterEmail
Contributing Editor

Contributing Editor account at Carthage Magazine. Tunisia's premier English general-interest Magazine with thousands of page-views per month and over 200,000 social media followers.

previous post
EU Says Tunisia is Welcome to ‘Wire Back’ the Money It Already Received
next post
Tunisia Reaffirms Full and Unconditional Support to Palestinian Cause

Related Articles

Tunisie Valeurs Named Best Broker for Tunisia in...

May 14, 2025

April 9th, Tunisian Martyrs’ Day 🇹🇳

April 2, 2025

Tunisia Central Bank Cuts Key Rate by 50...

March 26, 2025

Tunisia’s Inflation Drops to 6% in January

February 7, 2025

Tunicheque.tn: Revolutionizing Cheque Transactions in Tunisia

February 3, 2025

Tunisia Ranks as Africa’s 3rd Most Visited Country...

February 3, 2025

Tunisia Among National Geographic’s 25 Best Places to...

December 28, 2024

Djerba Island Listed Among World’s Top Destinations for...

December 27, 2024

Tunisian Olive Oil Makes Its Way to Cristiano...

December 26, 2024

Syria Has Officially Fallen, Marking the End of...

December 8, 2024

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Flavors of Tunisia

Taste-Tunisia-Tunisian-Cuisine-3

Want more top stories?

Carthage Magazine Newsletter

Sign up today and you’ll get our latest stories delivered straight to your inbox.

Just For You

  • 1

    El Jem Amphitheatre — The Greatest Roman Colosseum in North Africa

    January 19, 2024
  • 2

    Alcohol in Tunisia: What Visitors Need to Know

    August 2, 2021
  • 3

    Fruits From Tunisia: 15 Tunisian Fruits to Eat When Traveling

    August 20, 2023
  • 4

    The Great Mosque of Ez-Zitouna — Tunis’ Oldest & Most Significant Mosque

    June 2, 2023
  • 5

    Hannibal: The Last Hero of The Free World of Antiquity

    November 23, 2023

Latest

  • Tunisie Valeurs Named Best Broker for Tunisia in 2025

  • Tunisia Celebrates International Labor Day on May 1st

  • Former Tunisia President Fouad Mebazaa Dies at 91

  • April 9th, Tunisian Martyrs’ Day 🇹🇳

Sections

  • Editors' Picks
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Food & Drinks
  • Local History
  • News
  • No Sugarcoating
  • People
  • Quizzes
  • Style & Travel
  • Tech & Startups
  • Things to Do
  • Videos

E᙭ᑭᒪOᖇE

Carthage Magazine

We’re on a mission to create content that inspires people about experiences, places, products and people in Tunisia!

 

— About Us

— Adverstising

— Transparency

— Contact Us

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

ᗯᗩᑎT ᗰOᖇE TOᑭ ᔕTOᖇIEᔕ?

Carthage Magazine Newsletter

Sign up today and you’ll get our latest stories delivered straight to your inbox.

ᔕᑭᖇEᗩᗪ TᕼE ᗯOᖇᗪ

Spread the word

Our goal is to get these stories out in the public arena, and by doing this, keep promoting Tunisia and changing attitudes towards the MENA region.

 

— Ambassadors

— Readers Write

— What You Can Do to Help

EᗪITOᖇᔕ’ ᑭIᑕKᔕ

  • Tunisian Mloukhiya, Your Grandma’s Favorite Dish (& Likely Yours, Too!)

    April 2, 2025
  • Tunisia’s Favorite Pastry: Kaak Warka — A Taste of Heaven

    March 26, 2025
  • The Best Authentic Tunisian Rice Dish — “Rouz Jerbi”

    March 26, 2025

© 2019 - 2025 Carthage Magazine. Privacy Policy

Carthage Magazine
  • Home
  • News
  • Food & Drinks
    • Taste Tunisia
  • People
    • Interviews
    • No Sugarcoating
    • Environment
  • Style & Travel
    • Attractions
    • Trip Planning
      • Travel Information
      • Hotels in Tunisia
      • Cost of Living
      • Tunisia’s Language
      • Tunisia’s Weather
      • Tunisia’s Currency
      • Tunisia’s Visa
    • Transport in Tunisia
      • Traveling Around
      • Local Transport
      • Flights to Tunisia
      • Ferries to Tunisia
      • Tunisia Overland
    • Things to Do
      • Leisure
  • Local History
    • Museums
    • Monuments
    • Heritage Sites
    • Historical Figures
  • Education
  • Tech & Startups
  • Editors’ Picks
Carthage Magazine
  • Home
  • News
  • Food & Drinks
    • Taste Tunisia
  • People
    • Interviews
    • No Sugarcoating
    • Environment
  • Style & Travel
    • Attractions
    • Trip Planning
      • Travel Information
      • Hotels in Tunisia
      • Cost of Living
      • Tunisia’s Language
      • Tunisia’s Weather
      • Tunisia’s Currency
      • Tunisia’s Visa
    • Transport in Tunisia
      • Traveling Around
      • Local Transport
      • Flights to Tunisia
      • Ferries to Tunisia
      • Tunisia Overland
    • Things to Do
      • Leisure
  • Local History
    • Museums
    • Monuments
    • Heritage Sites
    • Historical Figures
  • Education
  • Tech & Startups
  • Editors’ Picks
© 2019 - 2025 Carthage Magazine. Privacy Policy

Read alsox

Israel Enforces ‘Complete Siege’ of Gaza

October 10, 2023

Stabbing of A Tunisian in Germany by...

January 28, 2024

Events Near You: Vecosterre | Bizerte

August 10, 2020